{"schema":"starlight.atlas.article.v1","status":"editorial_draft","editorial_notice":"Public editorial drafts. Source inspection and claim standing describe the recorded evidence; they do not establish independent replication or scientific consensus.","coverage":{"search_completed_on":"2026-10-13","systematic_review":false,"geographic_exhaustiveness":false,"languages":["en"],"areas_inspected":["selected planetary-science and cosmology reports","Bennu sugar paper analytical findings and limitations","DESI DR2 dark-energy paper relevant sections and distinct DR1 public release","Saguaro synthetic-redshift paper relevant sections","Pompeii institutional report and indexed primary excerpts/correction notice"],"limits":["Five selected topics only; no claim to exhaustive or latest-per-field coverage.","Separate editorial agent re-inspected institutional reports and relevant sections of Bennu, DESI and Saguaro papers; Pompeii primary text/notice inspected through search indexing.","Webb paper full text, Pompeii live full text/supplements and IOP Saguaro journal version remain retrieval gaps.","Bennu Crossmark and selected arXiv version histories inspected; Pompeii affiliation correction recorded. No exhaustive global corrections/retraction or replication search occurred.","No raw-data reanalysis, computational/physical replication or independent scientific validation occurred."]},"projection":{"source_repository":"frankxai/starlight-knowledge-tree","source_path":"data/atlas/corpus.json","source_commit":"133a478962a07c2d38637a5f9eaee54ffbebdf52","content_sha256":"64cc80fc5c9ef92fbd4da1ebea30b1e7af1a8f9c3fe809db0a191671adb1e7ee","compiled_on":"2026-10-13"},"article":{"id":"article-bennu-sugars","slug":"bennu-sugars","title":"Bennu and the chemistry before life","domain_id":"domain-biology","lens":"frontier","editorial_hook":"An analytical result at the boundary between chemistry and life's origins.","claim_ids":["claim-bennu-detection","claim-bennu-isotope-limit"],"related_source_ids":["source-bennu-sugars"],"question":"How would independent aliquots and stronger origin diagnostics change the interpretation?","graph_mapping_proposal":["domain-bio-human-intelligence","domain-space-builder"],"publication_status":"editorial_draft","created_on":"2026-10-13"},"claims":[{"id":"claim-bennu-detection","article_id":"article-bennu-sugars","revision":2,"text":"GC-MS and GC-MS/MS analyses identified ribose and glucose, among other sugars, in extract from a 603.4-mg Bennu aliquot (OREX-800107-108).","claim_kind":"observation","standing":"supported_within_scope","scope":"One homogenized returned-sample aliquot; identification cross-checked with a second instrument/column within the same study.","limits":"This is a chemical identification, not evidence of organisms. Procedural blanks and contamination controls support the interpretation but do not replace sugar-specific isotope or chirality measurements.","evidence":[{"source_id":"source-bennu-sugars","relation":"supports","locator":"Detection of Bennu sugars: aliquot and analytical-identification paragraphs; Figs. 1–3","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."},{"source_id":"source-bennu-sugars","relation":"qualifies","locator":"Detection of Bennu sugars: contamination discussion and paragraph beginning with total sugar abundance","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."}],"canonical_claim_ref":null,"review":{"status":"draft","method":"separate_agent_scoped_source_cross_check","independent_review":false,"scope":"Independent editorial pass within the same agent team; not independent scientific validation or replication.","receipt_ref":"docs/atlas/source-review-2026-10-13.md"},"first_recorded_on":"2026-10-13","last_source_checked_on":"2026-10-13","next_review_on":"2026-11-12"},{"id":"claim-bennu-isotope-limit","article_id":"article-bennu-sugars","revision":2,"text":"The authors report that low sugar abundance, interfering molecules and available sample mass prevented stable-isotope and enantiomeric measurements of the detected sugars.","claim_kind":"boundary_condition","standing":"supported_within_scope","scope":"Reported sugar measurements.","limits":"These measurements were not obtained for the sugars in this study; origin arguments rely on sample provenance, analytical controls and chemical context. Their absence neither establishes contamination nor proves an extraterrestrial origin.","evidence":[{"source_id":"source-bennu-sugars","relation":"supports","locator":"Detection of Bennu sugars: paragraph immediately before the hot-water-extract pH discussion","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."}],"canonical_claim_ref":null,"review":{"status":"draft","method":"separate_agent_scoped_source_cross_check","independent_review":false,"scope":"Independent editorial pass within the same agent team; not independent scientific validation or replication.","receipt_ref":"docs/atlas/source-review-2026-10-13.md"},"first_recorded_on":"2026-10-13","last_source_checked_on":"2026-10-13","next_review_on":"2026-11-12"}],"sources":[{"id":"source-bennu-sugars","title":"Bio-essential sugars in samples from asteroid Bennu","url":"https://doi.org/10.1038/s41561-025-01838-6","kind":"research_paper","published_on":"2025-12-02","updated_on":null,"issue_on":"2026-01-01","event_on":null,"accessed_on":"2026-10-13","language":"en","lineage_id":"lineage-furukawa-bennu-sugars","inspection":"relevant_sections","inspected_locators":["Abstract; Detection of Bennu sugars (sample OREX-800107-108, 603.4 mg, GC-MS/GC-MS/MS, Figs. 1–3); analytical blanks and contamination discussion; isotope/enantiomeric limitation; publication metadata; Crossmark"],"update_status":"no_update_listed_in_inspected_crossmark","rights":{"full_text_redistribution":"not_granted","stored_content":"bibliographic_metadata_and_original_paraphrase","media_included":false},"doi":"10.1038/s41561-025-01838-6","publication_stage":"peer_reviewed_version_of_record","issue_date_precision":"month","retrieval_note":"Relevant publisher full-text sections accessed through its cookie-error URL; subsequent canonical URL requests failed. Crossmark date/status page separately inspected.","update_check_scope":"Crossmark publisher record says future updates will be listed; this is a bounded status-page check, not an exhaustive corrections/retraction search.","issue_date_note":"January 2026 is the verified issue month. The day 01 in issue_on is a normalization, not a verified issue day.","update_check_url":"https://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1038/s41561-025-01838-6","update_checked_on":"2026-10-13","authors":["Yoshihiro Furukawa","Sako Sunami","Yoshinori Takano","Toshiki Koga","Yuta Hirakawa","Yasuhiro Oba","Hiroshi Naraoka","Daisuke Saigusa","Takaaki Yoshikawa","Satoru Tanaka","Daniel P. Glavin","Jason P. Dworkin","Harold C. Connolly Jr.","Dante S. Lauretta"]}],"citation_source_ids":["source-bennu-sugars"]}