{"schema_version":"starlight.atlas.v1","title":"Starlight Atlas","status":"editorial_draft","editorial_notice":"Public editorial drafts. Source inspection and claim standing describe the recorded evidence; they do not establish independent replication or scientific consensus.","created_on":"2026-10-13","license":"not_assigned_pending_owner_review","coverage":{"search_completed_on":"2026-10-13","systematic_review":false,"geographic_exhaustiveness":false,"languages":["en"],"areas_inspected":["selected planetary-science and cosmology reports","Bennu sugar paper analytical findings and limitations","DESI DR2 dark-energy paper relevant sections and distinct DR1 public release","Saguaro synthetic-redshift paper relevant sections","Pompeii institutional report and indexed primary excerpts/correction notice"],"limits":["Five selected topics only; no claim to exhaustive or latest-per-field coverage.","Separate editorial agent re-inspected institutional reports and relevant sections of Bennu, DESI and Saguaro papers; Pompeii primary text/notice inspected through search indexing.","Webb paper full text, Pompeii live full text/supplements and IOP Saguaro journal version remain retrieval gaps.","Bennu Crossmark and selected arXiv version histories inspected; Pompeii affiliation correction recorded. No exhaustive global corrections/retraction or replication search occurred.","No raw-data reanalysis, computational/physical replication or independent scientific validation occurred."]},"domains":[{"id":"domain-mathematics","label":"Mathematics & logic","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-physics","label":"Physics & quantum systems","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-cosmos","label":"Stars, cosmology & space technology","coverage":"seed_drafts_only","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-energy","label":"Energy & propulsion","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-materials","label":"Chemistry & materials","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-compute","label":"Computing & information","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-ai","label":"AI, agents & robotics","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-biology","label":"Biology & origins of life","coverage":"seed_drafts_only","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-medicine","label":"Medicine & longevity","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-mind","label":"Mind, cognition & consciousness","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-earth","label":"Earth, climate & oceans","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-ecology","label":"Ecology & agriculture","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-engineering","label":"Engineering & manufacturing","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-history","label":"Archaeology & historical technologies","coverage":"seed_drafts_only","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-language","label":"Languages, texts & knowledge transmission","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-culture","label":"Art, music & cultural traditions","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-society","label":"Economics, institutions & governance","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true},{"id":"domain-philosophy","label":"Philosophy, ethics & theology","coverage":"unreviewed","proposed":true}],"sources":[{"id":"source-webb-collisions","title":"Webb provides crash course on planet-shattering collisions","url":"https://esawebb.org/news/weic2618/","kind":"institutional_research_report","published_on":"2026-10-01","updated_on":null,"issue_on":null,"event_on":null,"accessed_on":"2026-10-13","language":"en","lineage_id":"lineage-su-extreme-debris-discs","inspection":"relevant_sections","inspected_locators":["Dated release; sample paragraph (21 systems: 16 Webb, 5 archival Spitzer); mineralogy and collision interpretation; explicit age/sample limitation"],"update_status":"not_independently_checked","rights":{"full_text_redistribution":"not_granted","stored_content":"bibliographic_metadata_and_original_paraphrase","media_included":false},"retrieval_note":"ESA/Webb institutional release directly inspected. Full IOP paper retrieval failed."},{"id":"source-bennu-sugars","title":"Bio-essential sugars in samples from asteroid Bennu","url":"https://doi.org/10.1038/s41561-025-01838-6","kind":"research_paper","published_on":"2025-12-02","updated_on":null,"issue_on":"2026-01-01","event_on":null,"accessed_on":"2026-10-13","language":"en","lineage_id":"lineage-furukawa-bennu-sugars","inspection":"relevant_sections","inspected_locators":["Abstract; Detection of Bennu sugars (sample OREX-800107-108, 603.4 mg, GC-MS/GC-MS/MS, Figs. 1–3); analytical blanks and contamination discussion; isotope/enantiomeric limitation; publication metadata; Crossmark"],"update_status":"no_update_listed_in_inspected_crossmark","rights":{"full_text_redistribution":"not_granted","stored_content":"bibliographic_metadata_and_original_paraphrase","media_included":false},"doi":"10.1038/s41561-025-01838-6","publication_stage":"peer_reviewed_version_of_record","issue_date_precision":"month","retrieval_note":"Relevant publisher full-text sections accessed through its cookie-error URL; subsequent canonical URL requests failed. Crossmark date/status page separately inspected.","update_check_scope":"Crossmark publisher record says future updates will be listed; this is a bounded status-page check, not an exhaustive corrections/retraction search.","issue_date_note":"January 2026 is the verified issue month. The day 01 in issue_on is a normalization, not a verified issue day.","update_check_url":"https://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1038/s41561-025-01838-6","update_checked_on":"2026-10-13","authors":["Yoshihiro Furukawa","Sako Sunami","Yoshinori Takano","Toshiki Koga","Yuta Hirakawa","Yasuhiro Oba","Hiroshi Naraoka","Daisuke Saigusa","Takaaki Yoshikawa","Satoru Tanaka","Daniel P. Glavin","Jason P. Dworkin","Harold C. Connolly Jr.","Dante S. Lauretta"]},{"id":"source-pompeii-mit","title":"Pompeii offers insights into ancient Roman building technology","url":"https://news.mit.edu/2025/pompeii-offers-insights-ancient-roman-building-technology-1209","kind":"institutional_research_report","published_on":"2025-12-09","updated_on":null,"issue_on":null,"event_on":null,"accessed_on":"2026-10-13","language":"en","lineage_id":"lineage-vaserman-weaver-pompeii-hot-mixing","inspection":"relevant_sections","inspected_locators":["Report date/author; Uncovering ancient secrets: site samples, dry quicklime mixture, stable-isotope interpretation; limits on generalizing the recipe"],"update_status":"not_independently_checked","rights":{"full_text_redistribution":"not_granted","stored_content":"bibliographic_metadata_and_original_paraphrase","media_included":false},"retrieval_note":"Institutional report directly inspected; source paper remains same research lineage.","report_author":"Zach Winn"},{"id":"source-pompeii-paper","title":"An unfinished Pompeian construction site reveals ancient Roman building technology","url":"https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-025-66634-7","kind":"research_paper","published_on":"2025-12-09","updated_on":"2026-01-30","issue_on":null,"event_on":null,"accessed_on":"2026-10-13","language":"en","lineage_id":"lineage-vaserman-weaver-pompeii-hot-mixing","inspection":"relevant_sections","inspected_locators":["Primary publisher search-index excerpts: Abstract; Results / Evidence of construction activities (room 14 dry material pile); hot-mixing analysis; Change history / 30 January 2026; About this article"],"update_status":"affiliation_correction_recorded","rights":{"full_text_redistribution":"not_granted","stored_content":"bibliographic_metadata_and_original_paraphrase","media_included":false},"doi":"10.1038/s41467-025-66634-7","publication_stage":"peer_reviewed_version_of_record","retrieval_limit":"Direct publisher HTML/PDF redirects and PMC bot challenge blocked live full-text access. Relevant primary full-text excerpts and dated correction notice were inspected through web search indexing; supplement, raw data and complete current text were not inspected.","retrieval_mode":"primary_site_search_index","update_check_scope":"Publisher and PMC search-index records expose a 30 January 2026 author-affiliation correction for Claire Hayhow and Kristin Bergmann. The retrieved notice reports affiliation changes; no change to the inspected scientific claim text is described.","source_license_reported":"CC BY-NC-ND 4.0; bibliographic records and original paraphrases only are included here.","update_check_url":"https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-025-66634-7","update_checked_on":"2026-10-13","authors":["Ellie Vaserman","James C. Weaver","Claire Hayhow","Kristin Bergmann","Celestino Grifa","Roberto Scalesse","Valeria Amoretti","Antonino Russo","Gennaro Iovino","Gabriel Zuchtriegel","Admir Masic"]},{"id":"source-desi-dr2","title":"More Than a Hint of Evolving Dark Energy — New Results and Data from DESI","url":"https://www.desi.lbl.gov/2025/03/19/more-than-a-hint-of-evolving-dark-energy-new-results-and-data-from-desi/","kind":"collaboration_research_report","published_on":"2025-03-19","updated_on":null,"issue_on":null,"event_on":null,"accessed_on":"2026-10-13","language":"en","lineage_id":"lineage-desi-dr2-cosmology","inspection":"relevant_sections","inspected_locators":["Dated announcement; three-year dataset and qualified dark-energy conclusion"],"update_status":"not_independently_checked","rights":{"full_text_redistribution":"not_granted","stored_content":"bibliographic_metadata_and_original_paraphrase","media_included":false}},{"id":"source-lrd-nasa","title":"NASA Webb Explores Family Tree of Newly Discovered Distant Objects","url":"https://science.nasa.gov/missions/webb/nasa-webb-explores-family-tree-of-newly-discovered-distant-objects/","kind":"institutional_research_report","published_on":"2026-07-29","updated_on":"2026-09-21","issue_on":null,"event_on":null,"accessed_on":"2026-10-13","language":"en","lineage_id":"lineage-rinaldi-saguaro-lrds","inspection":"relevant_sections","inspected_locators":["Saguaro case study; synthetic redshifting; representativeness limitation; original publication and update dates"],"update_status":"not_independently_checked","rights":{"full_text_redistribution":"not_granted","stored_content":"bibliographic_metadata_and_original_paraphrase","media_included":false},"report_author":"NASA Webb Mission Team"},{"id":"source-webb-paper","title":"Extreme Debris Disks: Insights into Violent Collisions in Planet Formation and Destruction","url":"https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ae88fe","kind":"research_paper","published_on":"2026-10-01","updated_on":null,"issue_on":null,"event_on":null,"accessed_on":"2026-10-13","language":"en","lineage_id":"lineage-su-extreme-debris-discs","inspection":"abstract_only","inspected_locators":["Publisher title, authors and publication date via primary-site search index; abstract from arXiv record 2607.06684"],"update_status":"not_independently_checked","rights":{"full_text_redistribution":"not_granted","stored_content":"bibliographic_metadata_and_original_paraphrase","media_included":false},"doi":"10.3847/1538-4357/ae88fe","publication_stage":"peer_reviewed_version_of_record","retrieval_limit":"IOP full text and direct arXiv HTML/abstract retrieval failed. Only indexed abstract and metadata inspected; no new claim-support edge relies on uninspected full text.","preprint_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.06684","first_preprint_on":"2026-07-07"},{"id":"source-desi-analysis-report","title":"New DESI Results Strengthen Hints That Dark Energy May Evolve","url":"https://newscenter.lbl.gov/2025/03/19/new-desi-results-strengthen-hints-that-dark-energy-may-evolve/","kind":"institutional_research_report","published_on":"2025-03-19","updated_on":null,"issue_on":null,"event_on":null,"accessed_on":"2026-10-13","language":"en","lineage_id":"lineage-desi-dr2-cosmology","inspection":"relevant_sections","inspected_locators":["DESI-alone Lambda-CDM compatibility; combination with CMB/supernovae/lensing; 2.8–4.2 sigma qualification; distinct DR1 public release"],"update_status":"not_independently_checked","rights":{"full_text_redistribution":"not_granted","stored_content":"bibliographic_metadata_and_original_paraphrase","media_included":false}},{"id":"source-desi-analysis-paper","title":"DESI DR2 Results II: Measurements of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations and Cosmological Constraints","url":"https://arxiv.org/html/2503.14738v3","kind":"research_paper","published_on":"2025-03-18","updated_on":"2025-10-09","issue_on":null,"event_on":null,"accessed_on":"2026-10-13","language":"en","lineage_id":"lineage-desi-dr2-cosmology","inspection":"relevant_sections","inspected_locators":["Abstract; VII / Dark-energy constraints; Fig. 11, Table 6; summary; arXiv submission/version history"],"update_status":"version_history_inspected","rights":{"full_text_redistribution":"not_granted","stored_content":"bibliographic_metadata_and_original_paraphrase","media_included":false},"doi":"10.1103/tr6y-kpc6","publication_stage":"arxiv_version_matched_to_published_article","retrieval_limit":"Relevant arXiv v3 sections inspected; journal full text/status and data/code not independently reviewed.","update_check_scope":"arXiv v1 18 March 2025; v2 26 March 2025; v3 9 October 2025 states updated to match Physical Review D. Journal correction/retraction history was not independently checked.","arxiv_id":"2503.14738","inspected_version":"v3","date_note":"published_on is initial arXiv submission, not a verified journal publication date. DOI identifies the journal paper.","update_checked_on":"2026-10-13","authors":["DESI Collaboration"]},{"id":"source-desi-public-release","title":"DESI Opens Access to the Largest 3D Map of the Universe Yet","url":"https://newscenter.lbl.gov/2025/03/19/desi-opens-access-to-the-largest-3d-map-of-the-universe-yet/","kind":"institutional_research_report","published_on":"2025-03-19","updated_on":null,"issue_on":null,"event_on":null,"accessed_on":"2026-10-13","language":"en","lineage_id":"lineage-desi-dr1-public-release","inspection":"relevant_sections","inspected_locators":["18.7M object total and category counts; DR1 designation; first-13-month coverage; public access statement"],"update_status":"not_independently_checked","rights":{"full_text_redistribution":"not_granted","stored_content":"bibliographic_metadata_and_original_paraphrase","media_included":false}},{"id":"source-lrd-paper","title":"Beyond the Dot: an LRD-like nucleus at the Heart of an IR-Bright Galaxy and its implications for high-redshift LRDs","url":"https://arxiv.org/html/2507.17738v2","kind":"research_paper","published_on":"2025-07-23","updated_on":"2026-06-16","issue_on":null,"event_on":null,"accessed_on":"2026-10-13","language":"en","lineage_id":"lineage-rinaldi-saguaro-lrds","inspection":"relevant_sections","inspected_locators":["Abstract; synthetic redshifting / Fig. 6 and toy-experiment assumptions; heterogeneous-LRD/evolutionary-path limitations; arXiv history; institutional published-version metadata"],"update_status":"version_history_inspected","rights":{"full_text_redistribution":"not_granted","stored_content":"bibliographic_metadata_and_original_paraphrase","media_included":false},"doi":"10.3847/1538-4357/ae80cd","publication_stage":"arxiv_preprint_v2_with_published_version_metadata_cross_checked","retrieval_limit":"IOP journal version could not be retrieved directly. Relevant arXiv v2 sections inspected; data/code and journal correction history were not reviewed.","update_check_scope":"arXiv initial submission 23 July 2025 and v2 revision 16 June 2026 inspected; institutional record gives journal publication 29 July 2026. Journal correction/retraction history not independently checked.","arxiv_id":"2507.17738","inspected_version":"v2","date_note":"published_on is initial arXiv submission; journal_published_on is separately verified metadata.","published_version_metadata_url":"https://research-explorer.ista.ac.at/record/22950","journal_published_on":"2026-07-29","update_checked_on":"2026-10-13","authors":["Pierluigi Rinaldi","George H. Rieke","Zihao Wu","Carys J. E. Gilbert","Fabio Pacucci","Luigi Barchiesi","Stacey Alberts","Stefano Carniani","Andrew J. Bunker","Rachana Bhatawdekar","Francesco D'Eugenio","Zhiyuan Ji","Benjamin D. Johnson","Kevin Hainline","Vasily Kokorev","Nimisha Kumari","Edoardo Iani","Jianwei Lyu","Roberto Maiolino","Eleonora Parlanti","Brant E. Robertson","Yang Sun","Cristian Vignali","Christina C. Williams","Christopher N. A. Willmer","Yongda Zhu"]}],"claims":[{"id":"claim-debris-sample","article_id":"article-planet-collisions","revision":2,"text":"The reported sample comprised 21 extreme debris-disc systems, combining observations of 16 systems with Webb and five from archival Spitzer data.","claim_kind":"observation","standing":"supported_within_scope","scope":"Reported sample and telescope allocation; not all young planetary systems.","limits":"Institutional release inspected; underlying paper abstract/metadata cross-checked but full text and raw spectra remain uninspected.","evidence":[{"source_id":"source-webb-collisions","relation":"supports","locator":"Science release: sample paragraph, beginning with rarity and the 21-disc sample","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."}],"canonical_claim_ref":null,"review":{"status":"draft","method":"separate_agent_scoped_source_cross_check","independent_review":false,"scope":"Independent editorial pass within the same agent team; not independent scientific validation or replication.","receipt_ref":"docs/atlas/source-review-2026-10-13.md"},"first_recorded_on":"2026-10-13","last_source_checked_on":"2026-10-13","next_review_on":"2026-11-12"},{"id":"claim-debris-interpretation","article_id":"article-planet-collisions","revision":2,"text":"The authors interpret silica-rich debris as evidence consistent with energetic collisions between large planetary bodies.","claim_kind":"inference","standing":"tentative","scope":"Authors' interpretation of silica-rich spectra in a selected sample.","limits":"Planetary impacts and impactor sizes are inferred from spectra and physical models. Collisions were not directly observed; mineralogy/age interpretation remains to be tested in larger samples.","evidence":[{"source_id":"source-webb-collisions","relation":"supports","locator":"Science release: mineralogical categories and approximately one-third silica-rich fraction","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."}],"canonical_claim_ref":null,"review":{"status":"draft","method":"separate_agent_scoped_source_cross_check","independent_review":false,"scope":"Independent editorial pass within the same agent team; not independent scientific validation or replication.","receipt_ref":"docs/atlas/source-review-2026-10-13.md"},"first_recorded_on":"2026-10-13","last_source_checked_on":"2026-10-13","next_review_on":"2026-11-12"},{"id":"claim-bennu-detection","article_id":"article-bennu-sugars","revision":2,"text":"GC-MS and GC-MS/MS analyses identified ribose and glucose, among other sugars, in extract from a 603.4-mg Bennu aliquot (OREX-800107-108).","claim_kind":"observation","standing":"supported_within_scope","scope":"One homogenized returned-sample aliquot; identification cross-checked with a second instrument/column within the same study.","limits":"This is a chemical identification, not evidence of organisms. Procedural blanks and contamination controls support the interpretation but do not replace sugar-specific isotope or chirality measurements.","evidence":[{"source_id":"source-bennu-sugars","relation":"supports","locator":"Detection of Bennu sugars: aliquot and analytical-identification paragraphs; Figs. 1–3","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."},{"source_id":"source-bennu-sugars","relation":"qualifies","locator":"Detection of Bennu sugars: contamination discussion and paragraph beginning with total sugar abundance","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."}],"canonical_claim_ref":null,"review":{"status":"draft","method":"separate_agent_scoped_source_cross_check","independent_review":false,"scope":"Independent editorial pass within the same agent team; not independent scientific validation or replication.","receipt_ref":"docs/atlas/source-review-2026-10-13.md"},"first_recorded_on":"2026-10-13","last_source_checked_on":"2026-10-13","next_review_on":"2026-11-12"},{"id":"claim-bennu-isotope-limit","article_id":"article-bennu-sugars","revision":2,"text":"The authors report that low sugar abundance, interfering molecules and available sample mass prevented stable-isotope and enantiomeric measurements of the detected sugars.","claim_kind":"boundary_condition","standing":"supported_within_scope","scope":"Reported sugar measurements.","limits":"These measurements were not obtained for the sugars in this study; origin arguments rely on sample provenance, analytical controls and chemical context. Their absence neither establishes contamination nor proves an extraterrestrial origin.","evidence":[{"source_id":"source-bennu-sugars","relation":"supports","locator":"Detection of Bennu sugars: paragraph immediately before the hot-water-extract pH discussion","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."}],"canonical_claim_ref":null,"review":{"status":"draft","method":"separate_agent_scoped_source_cross_check","independent_review":false,"scope":"Independent editorial pass within the same agent team; not independent scientific validation or replication.","receipt_ref":"docs/atlas/source-review-2026-10-13.md"},"first_recorded_on":"2026-10-13","last_source_checked_on":"2026-10-13","next_review_on":"2026-11-12"},{"id":"claim-pompeii-quicklime","article_id":"article-roman-concrete","revision":2,"text":"The Pompeii investigation found quicklime granules dry-mixed with pozzolan in a preserved room-14 material pile at Regio IX, Insula 10.","claim_kind":"historical_evidence","standing":"supported_within_scope","scope":"Specific preserved construction site buried in 79 CE.","limits":"Relevant primary-paper excerpts and institutional report inspected. Live full-text retrieval remains blocked; supplements/raw data were not inspected. The January 2026 affiliation correction is recorded.","evidence":[{"source_id":"source-pompeii-paper","relation":"supports","locator":"Results / Evidence of construction activities: room 14 pre-mixed pile (primary publisher indexed excerpt)","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."},{"source_id":"source-pompeii-mit","relation":"supports","locator":"Uncovering ancient secrets: intact quicklime fragments in dry material pile","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."}],"canonical_claim_ref":null,"review":{"status":"draft","method":"separate_agent_scoped_source_cross_check","independent_review":false,"scope":"Independent editorial pass within the same agent team; not independent scientific validation or replication.","receipt_ref":"docs/atlas/source-review-2026-10-13.md"},"first_recorded_on":"2026-10-13","last_source_checked_on":"2026-10-13","next_review_on":"2026-11-12"},{"id":"claim-pompeii-hotmix","article_id":"article-roman-concrete","revision":2,"text":"The investigators interpret the site evidence as supporting hot mixing during Roman construction.","claim_kind":"inference","standing":"supported_within_scope","scope":"Studied Pompeii site and materials; comparison of raw mix and wall/repair specimens.","limits":"The evidence supports this construction practice at this site; it does not establish a universal Roman recipe or prove that reconstructed mixes meet modern performance requirements. Full text/data remain retrieval gaps.","evidence":[{"source_id":"source-pompeii-paper","relation":"supports","locator":"Abstract and Results: dry quicklime/pozzolan mixture before water; raw pile and unfinished walls (primary publisher indexed excerpts)","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."},{"source_id":"source-pompeii-mit","relation":"supports","locator":"Uncovering ancient secrets: stable-isotope interpretation and preparation sequence","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."}],"canonical_claim_ref":null,"review":{"status":"draft","method":"separate_agent_scoped_source_cross_check","independent_review":false,"scope":"Independent editorial pass within the same agent team; not independent scientific validation or replication.","receipt_ref":"docs/atlas/source-review-2026-10-13.md"},"first_recorded_on":"2026-10-13","last_source_checked_on":"2026-10-13","next_review_on":"2026-11-12"},{"id":"claim-desi-result","article_id":"article-dark-energy","revision":2,"text":"DESI DR2 analyses of the first three years, combined with CMB and supernova data under a two-parameter dark-energy model, strengthened the reported preference for evolving dark energy.","claim_kind":"inference","standing":"tentative","scope":"Specified dataset combinations and the w0–wa model; results depend on supernova sample and cosmological assumptions.","limits":"DESI BAO alone is consistent with Lambda-CDM and does not show a strong preference for evolution. Combined-data preferences are not a settled discovery; unknown systematics and modeling choices remain relevant. No data analysis was reproduced.","evidence":[{"source_id":"source-desi-analysis-paper","relation":"supports","locator":"Abstract; VII / Dark-energy constraints; Fig. 11 and Table 6; summary","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."},{"source_id":"source-desi-analysis-report","relation":"qualifies","locator":"Paragraph beginning Taken alone and paragraph on differing dataset combinations","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."}],"canonical_claim_ref":null,"review":{"status":"draft","method":"separate_agent_scoped_source_cross_check","independent_review":false,"scope":"Independent editorial pass within the same agent team; not independent scientific validation or replication.","receipt_ref":"docs/atlas/source-review-2026-10-13.md"},"first_recorded_on":"2026-10-13","last_source_checked_on":"2026-10-13","next_review_on":"2026-11-12"},{"id":"claim-desi-public-data","article_id":"article-dark-energy","revision":2,"text":"The separate public DESI Data Release 1 announcement reported information on 18.7 million galaxies, quasars and stars, covering the first 13 months of the main survey plus survey-validation data.","claim_kind":"observation","standing":"supported_within_scope","scope":"DESI DR1 public release announced 19 March 2025; distinct from the three-year DR2 cosmology analysis.","limits":"This is a release-description claim; dataset download, completeness and downstream updates were not tested.","evidence":[{"source_id":"source-desi-public-release","relation":"supports","locator":"Key Takeaways; object-count paragraph; first-year/main-survey and validation coverage paragraphs","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."}],"canonical_claim_ref":null,"review":{"status":"draft","method":"separate_agent_scoped_source_cross_check","independent_review":false,"scope":"Independent editorial pass within the same agent team; not independent scientific validation or replication.","receipt_ref":"docs/atlas/source-review-2026-10-13.md"},"first_recorded_on":"2026-10-13","last_source_checked_on":"2026-10-13","next_review_on":"2026-11-12"},{"id":"claim-lrd-simulation","article_id":"article-little-red-dots","revision":2,"text":"The Saguaro study synthetically redshifted its z = 2.0145 galaxy to z = 7 to illustrate how surface-brightness dimming could hide its extended host while leaving a compact LRD-like nucleus visible.","claim_kind":"model_result","standing":"supported_within_scope","scope":"A visual toy experiment with fitted spectral templates, instrumental/background assumptions and a phenomenological brightening prescription.","limits":"This is a model illustration, not observation of that galaxy in the early universe or a fitted evolutionary history. The authors explicitly describe its brightening choice as visual-purpose only.","evidence":[{"source_id":"source-lrd-paper","relation":"supports","locator":"Synthetic-redshift experiment: pixel SED redshifting, FERENGI-like prescription and Fig. 6","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."},{"source_id":"source-lrd-paper","relation":"qualifies","locator":"Paragraph beginning We stress that for this toy experiment","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."}],"canonical_claim_ref":null,"review":{"status":"draft","method":"separate_agent_scoped_source_cross_check","independent_review":false,"scope":"Independent editorial pass within the same agent team; not independent scientific validation or replication.","receipt_ref":"docs/atlas/source-review-2026-10-13.md"},"first_recorded_on":"2026-10-13","last_source_checked_on":"2026-10-13","next_review_on":"2026-11-12"},{"id":"claim-lrd-phase","article_id":"article-little-red-dots","revision":2,"text":"The team proposed that some little red dots could be visible nuclei of galaxies in a short-lived, perhaps AGN-dominated phase whose compact appearance is amplified by observational bias.","claim_kind":"inference","standing":"tentative","scope":"Proposed pathway motivated by Saguaro, other lower-redshift examples and the study's selected LRD analysis.","limits":"The physical nature and evolutionary pathways remain unresolved across the LRD population. Saguaro is not representative of all LRDs; the primary paper qualifies AGN dominance as a possibility.","evidence":[{"source_id":"source-lrd-paper","relation":"supports","locator":"Abstract: proposed short-lived, perhaps AGN-dominated evolutionary phase","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."},{"source_id":"source-lrd-nasa","relation":"qualifies","locator":"Final scientific discussion: Saguaro not representative of all LRDs","inspection_note":"Relevant source sections re-inspected by a separate editorial agent; no scientific replication performed."}],"canonical_claim_ref":null,"review":{"status":"draft","method":"separate_agent_scoped_source_cross_check","independent_review":false,"scope":"Independent editorial pass within the same agent team; not independent scientific validation or replication.","receipt_ref":"docs/atlas/source-review-2026-10-13.md"},"first_recorded_on":"2026-10-13","last_source_checked_on":"2026-10-13","next_review_on":"2026-11-12"}],"articles":[{"id":"article-planet-collisions","slug":"planet-shattering-collisions","title":"Reading planetary collisions in stardust","domain_id":"domain-cosmos","lens":"frontier","editorial_hook":"A path from spectroscopy to the history of rocky worlds.","claim_ids":["claim-debris-sample","claim-debris-interpretation"],"related_source_ids":["source-webb-collisions","source-webb-paper"],"question":"Which additional observations would discriminate collision mechanisms?","graph_mapping_proposal":["domain-space-builder"],"publication_status":"editorial_draft","created_on":"2026-10-13"},{"id":"article-bennu-sugars","slug":"bennu-sugars","title":"Bennu and the chemistry before life","domain_id":"domain-biology","lens":"frontier","editorial_hook":"An analytical result at the boundary between chemistry and life's origins.","claim_ids":["claim-bennu-detection","claim-bennu-isotope-limit"],"related_source_ids":["source-bennu-sugars"],"question":"How would independent aliquots and stronger origin diagnostics change the interpretation?","graph_mapping_proposal":["domain-bio-human-intelligence","domain-space-builder"],"publication_status":"editorial_draft","created_on":"2026-10-13"},{"id":"article-roman-concrete","slug":"roman-concrete-hot-mixing","title":"Recovering Roman material knowledge","domain_id":"domain-history","lens":"historical","editorial_hook":"Lost knowledge becomes useful when a surviving artifact can constrain its reconstruction.","claim_ids":["claim-pompeii-quicklime","claim-pompeii-hotmix"],"related_source_ids":["source-pompeii-mit","source-pompeii-paper"],"question":"How does a reconstructed mix perform against a matched modern material under specified conditions?","graph_mapping_proposal":[],"publication_status":"editorial_draft","created_on":"2026-10-13"},{"id":"article-dark-energy","slug":"desi-evolving-dark-energy","title":"Is dark energy changing?","domain_id":"domain-cosmos","lens":"frontier","editorial_hook":"A consequential question whose answer depends on observations and models.","claim_ids":["claim-desi-result","claim-desi-public-data"],"related_source_ids":["source-desi-dr2","source-desi-analysis-report","source-desi-analysis-paper","source-desi-public-release"],"question":"How sensitive is the result to model choices and independent datasets?","graph_mapping_proposal":["domain-space-builder"],"publication_status":"editorial_draft","created_on":"2026-10-13"},{"id":"article-little-red-dots","slug":"little-red-dots","title":"The unresolved identity of little red dots","domain_id":"domain-cosmos","lens":"frontier","editorial_hook":"Compact red sources make a useful case study in observation, simulation, and competing explanations.","claim_ids":["claim-lrd-simulation","claim-lrd-phase"],"related_source_ids":["source-lrd-nasa","source-lrd-paper"],"question":"Do other lower-redshift examples support the same proposed pathway?","graph_mapping_proposal":["domain-space-builder"],"publication_status":"editorial_draft","created_on":"2026-10-13"}],"projection":{"source_repository":"frankxai/starlight-knowledge-tree","source_path":"data/atlas/corpus.json","source_commit":"133a478962a07c2d38637a5f9eaee54ffbebdf52","content_sha256":"64cc80fc5c9ef92fbd4da1ebea30b1e7af1a8f9c3fe809db0a191671adb1e7ee","compiled_on":"2026-10-13"}}